XHTML Challenge

"XHTML Challenge is comparing websites based on validation and code markup in order to choose and vote the best coded sites"

Challenge: Best Web Gallery vs. CSS Remix

    • Voted as winner
      Best Web Gallery

      Best Web Gallery

      http://bestwebgallery.com/

      683 votes

      Doctype:
      XHTML 1.0 Transitional 
      Markup Validation:
      Yes
      Content length:
      21,554 bytes
      Markup ratio:
      84.00%
      Content ratio:
      7.46%
      Conditional comments:
      No
      Table count:
      0
      CSS Validation:

      CSS 3: Yes

      CSS 2.1: No (1 error)

      Analyzed: 25 April 2008

    • vs.
    • CSS Remix

      CSS Remix

      http://cssremix.com/

      210 votes

      Doctype:
      XHTML 1.0 Strict 
      Markup Validation:
      No (208 errors)
      Content length:
      90,336 bytes
      Markup ratio:
      88.38%
      Content ratio:
      7.32%
      Conditional comments:
      Yes
      Table count:
      0
      CSS Validation:

      CSS 3: No (10 errors)

      CSS 2.1: No (17 errors)

      Analyzed: 25 April 2008

Comments

  • David

    09:02 19/02/08

    I would love to know what people think of the new CSS Remix site design. To me it seems too tight and claustrophobic. I muuuch preferred the original design.

    Am I alone in thinking this?
  • simkamsan

    09:20 19/02/08

    CSS Remix is great site design. i love also.
  • CZephyr

    13:51 19/02/08

    David: I hate it. It's a poor use of space and typography.
    I didn't realize there was navigation until I squinted and looked around for a bit.
  • CoryMathews

    00:47 22/02/08

    CSS Remix site looks terrible. It looks like junk thrown together, then called a site. Much less the 107 errors its got. My vote goes to Best Web Gallery its a clean design, easy to follow, and much better coded.
  • Jason

    02:44 22/02/08

    It does look cramped and a little chaotic. An interesting design move.
  • Erwin

    13:09 22/02/08

    I don't prefer both. Cssremix is terrible (the previous design was better), the website is slow, its way to chaotic and the navigation is just terrible. Best web gallery is ok. Navigation is clear, but there are a lot of useless options (what's up with th
  • Sadmir Hamza

    21:13 22/02/08

    Hi,
    The Best Web Gallery, looks grate, who made it? I'm looking for something like that, where do I find it?

    Thank you
  • web design, almog , media

    10:10 25/02/08

    I would have to say that the old site looks and feels better.
  • Alvito

    20:12 25/02/08

    I liked the previous CSSRemix layout as well, this one seems to be missing out on loads of things ... it looks like someone's cluttered portfolio .. somewhere in the late 90's
  • bluEyez

    01:52 02/03/08

    the new design of css remix is like david sayd: tight and claustrophobic. old one better ( and i don't love so much the new color pallet )

    should be more clear and free and focused on the gallery
    if u noticed the website is made so you don't have to s
  • jazzebo

    02:09 03/03/08

    I only see the content in my newsreader and I think css remix has by far the better content of the two.
  • abdul hai khan

    20:17 04/03/08

    best web galley is very good site according to css remix.

    thanks
    abdul hai khan
    india web designer
  • Bali

    04:48 15/03/08

    I like CSS Remix, but I think the thumb in frontpage look like to strecth for me. It must be a little space between the thumb (IMO)
  • James

    01:32 17/03/08

    Well CSS Remix is not bad, but the content is so tight. Best Web Gallery have this little Layout Effect i like so much.
  • kashi

    07:02 04/04/08

    u r great but cssremix too good....

Add comment

  • No HTML allowed. Sorry!

Feel free to browse through the existing challenges or challenge other projects with your very own

« Challenge a website

Challenge Info

Created by: ndesign

Created on: 12 February 2008

Tags:

Advertisments

  • Slice'r'us: Designs to XHTML + CSS
  • CSS Gallery

Feeds

Grab our feed to stay informed of latest challenges: